Here, he teams with a young writer named Laura Terruso (who created the character of Doris for an acclaimed 2011 short called "Doris and the Intern") to write the kind of film that gifted actors are almost dying to get into. The supporting cast here is unbelievably deep, also featuring veteran indie screen darling Natasha Lyonne, Kyle Mooney of "SNL," Beth Behrs of CBS' hit sitcom "2 Broke Girls," "Silicon Valley" star Kumail Nanjiani and the ubiquitously unctuous Peter Gallagher in addition to the actors listed above. When quality actors like these line up ten deep for even a couple of lines in a movie, you know the script is something special.
What makes this movie magic isn't just its unique comic sensibility and sunny disposition – a trait that's all too rare in movies these days – but its ability to surprise viewers at key moments with the flip side of Doris' optimistic surface. Field expertly plays a woman who has harbored pain and disappointment for decades, and as she and John open up to each other about their respective hurts, viewers are drawn in to truly caring about them as well.
There are only two minor criticisms I can think of for "Doris," but they were both audibly expressed by other audience members at the crowded Tuesday matinee I attended. First, this is such a sweet and good-hearted movie, and Field's core audience is generally older and less given to edgy humor, that it's a shame when characters lapse into a fusillade of comic profanity in a couple of scenes.
It seems that Showalter and Terruso are making a subtle comment about how thoughtlessly crude the twentysomething generation can be in trying to carry on even basic conversations. These moments are jarring nonetheless and pointlessly give a movie that could easily be a great family film an R rating, which is certain to also limit the older audience for whom the film is a slam dunk entertainment. The scenes are in one cluster of the film, however, and easily forgiven by the end of the movie.
The other issue is the film's final shot, which leaves viewers with total ambiguity after investing themselves in this wonderful woman's life for 95 minutes. Does she find love and happiness, or doesn't she? It's momentarily maddening to wonder about that fact, but in its own way, leaving viewers with an ending that will engage their own imaginations may just be one more moment of this movie's magic. I can't recommend "Doris" highly enough.